Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: [Resolved] Is whitelisting broken?
SpamCop Discussion > Discussions & Observations > SpamCop Email System & Accounts
TimK
Hi everyone,

A message showed up a little while ago in my Held Mail. It's not spam, so in the Held Mail list I selected it and clicked on 'Release and Whitelist'. It disappeared from Held Mail...temporarily, as it turned out. I reported the other two messages that were in Held Mail and logged out of the Web mail interface.

When I looked in Thunderbird again a moment later, there was a message in Held Mail...and lo and behold, it was the message I'd released and whitelisted! I did release-and-whitelist three more times, and every time it showed up in Held Mail again.

I went into my whitelist under Options, thinking that perhaps the address wasn't added to my whitelist after all...but there it was. So it seems that the whitelist function isn't working correctly right now.

Can anyone shed any light?

Thanks,
Tim
Wazoo
How about possibly explaining the other side of the issue .. why is the e-mail in the Held folder to begin with? It may be that for some reason it's being tagged and moved before it gets to the point that a whitelist check would be performed.
TimK
QUOTE(Wazoo @ Jul 15 2006, 05:57 PM) *

How about possibly explaining the other side of the issue .. why is the e-mail in the Held folder to begin with? It may be that for some reason it's being tagged and moved before it gets to the point that a whitelist check would be performed.


The whole point of a whitelist function is to intercept mail from certain senders before it has a chance to get tagged and put in Held Mail. If that isn't how the whitelist works, then I don't see any point in even having it.
TimK
Hmm, never mind.

It appears Thunderbird was the culprit. It thought the message was spam and was moving it into Held Mail for me. :-)

Best,
Tim
Wazoo
QUOTE(TimK @ Jul 15 2006, 11:00 AM) *
The whole point of a whitelist function is to intercept mail from certain senders before it has a chance to get tagged and put in Held Mail. If that isn't how the whitelist works, then I don't see any point in even having it.

QUOTE(TimK @ Jul 15 2006, 12:50 PM) *
Hmm, never mind.

It appears Thunderbird was the culprit. It thought the message was spam and was moving it into Held Mail for me. :-)

I know that it appears that you were unhappy with my reply and didn't really want to respond to that .. but thanks for the feedback and update.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2009 Invision Power Services, Inc.